Lafayette rallies past William & Mary football 19-14 at Zable Stadium

William & Mary football led 14-0 early and lost 19-14 to Lafayette on Saturday at Walter J. Zable Stadium. The Tribe fell to 3-7 and did not score after the second quarter. Lafayette (4-5) scored 19 unanswered points.
Quick start for the Tribe
William & Mary scored on its first two touchdown drives, both quick. Winston Watkins threw a 68-yard touchdown pass to Carson Jenkins with 7:46 left in the first quarter, on a drive that took three plays and 59 seconds. Andrew King then ran 39 yards for a score with 11:44 left in the second quarter, capping a four-play, 71-yard drive. Max Lipinski kicked both extra points.
Lafayette got on the board with Jack Simonetta's 28-yard field goal with 1:53 left in the first half, which made it 14-3 at the break.
Leopards take over the second half
Jason Penza broke a 50-yard touchdown run with 2:33 left in the third quarter to cut the lead to 14-10. Simonetta added a 44-yard field goal with 12:52 left in the fourth, and Lafayette trailed 14-13.
Penza then threw a 12-yard touchdown pass to Mason Kuehner with 4:41 remaining. The two-point pass failed, leaving the score 19-14. Lafayette drove 80 yards on seven plays for that score.
Penza finished with 140 rushing yards on 21 carries, and Lafayette outgained the Tribe 401 yards to 275. The Leopards rushed for 251 yards on 49 carries and held the ball for 35:39, compared with 24:21 for William & Mary. Lafayette also converted 5 of 14 third downs to the Tribe's 3 of 13.
Final possession
After the go-ahead touchdown, William & Mary punted. Carter Boyd's 71-yard punt pinned Lafayette at its own 3. The Tribe took over at the Lafayette 42 after the Leopards punted. Watkins threw three straight incompletions, and the last was broken up by Jalen Edwards on fourth-and-10 for a turnover on downs with 1:41 left. Lafayette ran out the clock.
Individual numbers
Watkins completed 14 of 25 passes for 132 yards and a touchdown with no interceptions, and added 34 rushing yards. King ran 17 times for 96 yards and a score. Jenkins caught two passes for 71 yards and a touchdown.
Elijah Rainer led the Tribe with 14 tackles, followed by Ryan Matheny with 12. Christopher Higgins and Stephon Hicks each had 11. Higgins had a sack. Boyd punted nine times for a 45.1-yard average, with five landing inside the 20.
Lafayette's Callahan Blair had two sacks and three tackles for loss. Kuehner caught five passes for 58 yards and a score. Eddie Jordan was 11 of 20 for 130 yards, and Penza went 3 of 4 for 20 yards and a touchdown. The Tribe committed no turnovers; the Leopards lost one fumble. Attendance was 10,006.
Next up
William & Mary hosts Bucknell on Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026, at 1:00 p.m. ET.