WASHINGTON, D.C. • MARYLAND • VIRGINIAInstagram · @the_nsmt ↗
NSMT

Independent sports.
One DMV.

The Daily NewspaperSports. Stories. Your front page.

NSMT REPORT

Trade deadline: The Commanders should trade Stefon Diggs and keep Marcus Mariota

Trade deadline: The Commanders should trade Stefon Diggs and keep Marcus Mariota

The NFL trade deadline is today at 4 p.m. Eastern. Washington is 2-5-1, has not made a trade this season and plays at the first-place Giants on Thursday.

The NFL trade deadline is today at 4 p.m., and the Commanders arrive at it 2-5-1, three games out of first place, with the team they are chasing two days away. ESPN’s Football Power Index gives them a 5.8 percent chance of making the playoffs. That number should settle the first question. Washington should not be a buyer.

It does not have to be a seller in the fire-sale sense, either, and general manager Adam Peters has refused both labels. “I wouldn’t categorize us as either,” he said on 106.7 The Fan in mid-October, adding that “the give up part, that ain’t happening.” Last Friday he said of the Rams game, “The results of the game aren’t going to dictate what we do.” As of this morning none of the 12 trades made around the league since the season opened involved Washington.

The best chip is already gone. The Giants, of all teams, talked to Washington about defensive tackle Daron Payne, NFL insider Ian Rapoport reported, until Payne broke his left foot in practice on Oct. 30. He is on injured reserve, and his contract expires after the season.

Start with Stefon Diggs. He is 32, on a one-year contract and leads the team with five touchdown catches, which makes him exactly the rental a contender pays for. The Rams (5-4) are the first call. Puka Nacua, who caught 14 passes for 150 yards against Washington on Sunday, is likely headed to injured reserve with a knee injury and turf toe, coach Sean McVay said. Washington should at least find out what Diggs is worth, and The NSMT would take a fourth-round pick.

K’Lavon Chaisson, 27, who has 3.5 sacks and three forced fumbles on a one-year deal, Dorance Armstrong and tackle Andrew Wylie, the Commander ESPN’s Dan Graziano named as one who could move, deserve the same phone calls. Marcus Mariota does not. Minnesota is reported to be shopping for a quarterback, and that is the reason to hold him. Quarterbacks are at a premium everywhere, Mariota has already played in three games this season, and Washington should keep him behind Jayden Daniels unless an offer blows it away.

The needs are not hard to find. Washington converts 31.1 percent of its third downs, last in the NFL, has run the fewest offensive plays, and ranked last in ESPN’s run-block win rate through Week 8. It allows 240 passing yards a game. Terry McLaurin, Laremy Tunsil, Payne and Javon Kinlaw are all on injured reserve. That is a receiver, a left tackle and two defensive tackles.

One outside name has been tied to Washington: Colts receiver Josh Downs, 25, in the last year of his rookie contract. Jordan Schultz listed the Commanders among the teams to watch, and ESPN’s Adam Schefter reported that Indianapolis wants a third-round pick and turned down an offer that included a fourth. The Colts are also listening on defensive tackle Grover Stewart and running back Jonathan Taylor. ESPN’s John Keim wrote that any addition would be “not for this season alone but for the long haul.”

Washington can afford to act. It has $23.6 million in salary cap space, seventh most in the league, according to Over The Cap.

The NSMT’s plan: trade Diggs, listen on the other rentals, keep Mariota and keep the picks. Philadelphia got a first- and a second-round pick for Jordan Davis on Monday, so the market is paying. Downs is worth a fourth only if he signs to stay. Nothing that happens Thursday should change any of it.

The NSMT’s plan

Trade: Stefon Diggs (to the Rams, or the best offer), K’Lavon Chaisson, Dorance Armstrong and Andrew Wylie.

Keep: Marcus Mariota, unless an offer blows Washington away; Mike Sainristil; and the draft picks.

Call about: Josh Downs and Grover Stewart of the Colts, and Brian Thomas Jr. of the Jaguars.

All NSMT coverage →

NSMT COVERAGE

Find a story.