MLB
Alonso delivered but the Orioles still fell short in 2026

Pete Alonso gave Baltimore the middle-of-the-order production it paid for. The Orioles still finished another season looking up at the playoff field.
Their final record was 79-82, with the scheduled Sept. 27 finale at Yankee Stadium canceled because of rain and not rescheduled. Baltimore finished fourth in the American League East. The Orioles had already been eliminated on Sept. 24, so the rainout closed a season whose central disappointment was settled: a roster built to get back to October fell short again.
Alonso's first year became an argument for investing in established talent. The rest of the season became a warning about expecting one signing to carry a lineup, stabilize a clubhouse and cover the weaknesses around him. Baltimore improved by four wins from 2025, but its August trades and September mistakes left much harder questions than that modest improvement suggests.
The expectations were reasonable and the Orioles missed them
This was supposed to be a rebound year. Baltimore had hired Craig Albernaz as manager and added Alonso, Taylor Ward, Shane Baz, Chris Bassitt and Ryan Helsley to a roster that still included several players expected to form its long-term core. The winter brought enough change to make another losing season an unacceptable outcome, even without making the Orioles a clear division favorite.
There is a useful, dated benchmark. On March 24, BetMGM listed Baltimore's win total at 85.5. Its preview also cited a FanGraphs projection of 83.7 wins and identified an important imbalance: a highly regarded lineup paired with more uncertainty in the rotation. The final 79 wins fell 6.5 below that sportsbook benchmark and 4.7 below the cited projection. Even an additional victory in the canceled finale would have left Baltimore short of both.
Those numbers matter because expectations should be judged against what was actually forecast. The Orioles were not universally projected to run away with the AL East. They were expected to return to a winning record and compete seriously for a postseason berth. They stayed within reach late, but never made the sustained move that would turn proximity into control of their season.
Alonso supplied the star season
Alonso finished with 43 home runs and 113 RBIs, leading the American League in both categories. He was the unanimous choice for Most Valuable Oriole. He also played every one of Baltimore's 161 games, giving the club a dependable presence while other parts of the roster changed around him.
His .267 average backed up the power. For the first season of a five-year, $155 million commitment, Baltimore received exactly the kind of offensive centerpiece it had been seeking.
But the distance between Alonso and the next wave of production was telling. Coby Mayo's 24 home runs and 63 RBIs were encouraging, especially as Baltimore needed answers at third base. His .297 on-base percentage also showed how much room remained for his offensive game to develop. Power gave Mayo a meaningful role. reaching base more consistently would make that role considerably more valuable.
Gunnar Henderson produced 24 homers, but his .226 average and .715 OPS fell well below the standard he had established. At season's end, he disclosed a wrist issue that had affected him for roughly half the year. That context belongs in the evaluation, without pretending it explains every difficult at-bat or erases the need for a rebound.
Injuries complicated the younger core's progress, too. Jordan Westburg underwent Tommy John surgery in May, while Jackson Holliday's year began and ended with wrist-related absences. Samuel Basallo's season was interrupted by a shoulder problem and ended early with a concussion. These were meaningful losses. They also made it more important that the players available every day produce and defend consistently.
The deadline changed the meaning of the season
The most consequential move came Aug. 3, when Baltimore sent Adley Rutschman and Jake Rogers to Boston. The completed return included catcher Carlos Narváez, pitchers Anthony Eyanson and Kyson Witherspoon, and outfielders Enddy Azocar and Harold Rivas. The deal moved a familiar centerpiece of Baltimore's recent rise to a division rival and placed another large bet on the organization's next group of players.
Ward went to Seattle, Tyler Wells to Tampa Bay and Dean Kremer to Minnesota. Baltimore entered Aug. 4 at 54-58, only 2½ games out of a wild-card spot. That combination made the deadline particularly difficult to process: the standings still offered an opening, while the transactions acknowledged that the roster had not justified a conventional push for reinforcements.
The return on those trades cannot be judged fully in October. Prospect development takes time. The immediate conclusion is narrower: a season that began with veteran additions ended with Baltimore again moving established major leaguers for future value.
There were smaller additions worth carrying into the winter's evaluation. Christian Encarnacion-Strand hit .277 with 11 homers and 39 RBIs for Baltimore. He offered useful production without resolving the broader problem of building a balanced lineup.
The late opening disappeared
Baltimore reached 69-69 by beating Colorado on Aug. 31. It then lost six straight, including a four-game home sweep by Boston completed Sept. 6. The club had earned another opportunity to change the season's direction and immediately surrendered the ground it had gained.
The problems were visible beyond the standings. The Banner reported a 25 percent team strikeout rate, third-highest in the majors, and a season in which Baltimore did not win four consecutive games until July. At the season-ending news conference, the recurring subject was execution. The Orioles allowed an MLB-high 88 unearned runs.
Unearned runs are not a perfect measure of defensive quality, but that total helps explain why the repeated calls for cleaner baseball mattered. A club trying to climb out of the middle of the standings cannot repeatedly extend opponents' innings and expect its power hitters to repair the damage.
The pitching offered some answers
Brandon Young was among the year's most useful developments. He finished 9-6 with a 3.56 ERA across 28 starts and 156⅔ innings, giving Baltimore a substantial contribution from a pitcher who was not its headline winter acquisition.
Baz supplied 179⅔ innings with a 4.11 ERA. Trevor Rogers made 30 starts with a 4.03 ERA, while Kyle Bradish finished at 4.12. That group provided a foundation, but its performance did not eliminate the need to improve run prevention.
Rico Garcia deserves recognition for a 3.09 ERA, 0.97 WHIP and 10 saves across 75 appearances. He supplied dependable relief in a year when the planned ninth-inning arrangement did not hold. Elbow injuries limited Helsley's availability. Bassitt finished with a 4.59 ERA in 102 innings, a limited return from another important offseason addition.
Baltimore has already committed to Baz and Bradish beyond this season. On Sept. 28, Elias announced planned sports hernia surgery for Bradish, with no firm recovery timetable.
Whether the rotation takes a step forward now depends on more than bringing back familiar names. Health, command, defense behind the pitchers and the decision on Rogers all belong in the same discussion.
The offseason decisions are specific
The notable pending free agents include Rogers, Bassitt, Andrew Kittredge and Keegan Akin. Other situations involve options rather than automatic departures: Luis Robert Jr. has a $20 million club option for 2027, Ryan Mountcastle a $7.5 million club option, Zach Eflin a $25 million mutual option and Helsley a $14 million player option. Those categories matter when assessing how much of the roster could change.
RosterResource lists Henderson as arbitration-eligible for 2027 and Holliday and Mayo as pre-arbitration players. Alonso, Baz, Bradish and Basallo have longer-term contracts. A one-year salary entry for a controlled player should not be mistaken for impending free agency.
Rogers is the most immediate rotation question. Mike Elias said at the season-ending news conference that Baltimore wanted to keep him and intended to speak with his representatives before free agency and during it, if necessary. Interest is established. an agreement is not.
Elias is also seeking a general manager to work under him. That makes this an organizational review as well as a roster exercise. New titles will matter only if player development, preparation and execution improve.
The larger questions follow from what happened on the field. Can Henderson return to being the lineup's leading force alongside Alonso? Can Baltimore support Basallo adequately behind the plate after trading Rutschman? Can the infield become more reliable without sacrificing needed offense? And can the club turn the pitching it already has into more consistent results?
Alonso showed that a major addition can work. Young and Mayo supplied reasons to keep building. The next step is making those successes reinforce one another across a full season. After another October without Orioles baseball, that is the standard the winter's decisions will have to meet.